Alternative solution:
Since we know the roots are a and b, we know that \(7x^2 + x - 5 = 7(x - a)(x - b)\).
Expanding the right-hand side gives \(7x^2 + x - 5 = 7x^2 - 7(a + b)x + 7ab\).
Comparing the coefficients of x on both sides: \(1 = -7(a + b)\).
Therefore, \(a + b = -\dfrac17\).
Now, \((a - 4) + (b - 4) = (a + b) - 8\), using this gives \((a - 4) + (b - 4) = -\dfrac17 - 8 =\boxed{ -\dfrac{57}8}\).